Florida Rental Property Owners: Property Premiums Are Easing, but Watch Your Liability

Posted on November 15, 2026
If you own rental property in Tampa Bay, there is finally some good news on the property side of your insurance bill. New data on Southeast multifamily rates shows Florida property premiums have come down meaningfully, but liability costs are moving the other way. With hurricane season wrapping up on November 30, this is a smart time to review both before your next renewal.
What the latest numbers show
Insurance Journal reported this month on data from analytics firm Advocate Technologies covering more than 1,000 Florida properties:
The median Florida multifamily property premium fell from $797 per door in early 2025 to $479 per door in April 2026.
The median Florida liability premium went from $167 to $169 per door over roughly the same period, after briefly reaching $215 in a smaller sample.
Liability costs also rose in Georgia and other Southeastern states, which points to a broader trend.
On the personal lines side, the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation said in late October that more than 800,000 homeowners would see rate decreases on new policies or renewals, with more decreases expected in the coming months.
Why liability is heading the other direction
The report links the liability trend to lawsuits and larger jury verdicts, often called "social inflation," and describes it as structural rather than temporary. Florida's 2022 and 2023 reforms appear to have eased property claim litigation, but liability has not followed the same pattern. The report also cautions that property softening can reverse after one bad storm season, so today's pricing is not guaranteed to last.
Your year-end checklist for rental properties
Confirm your dwelling limits reflect today's rebuilding costs, not what you paid for the property.
Review your liability limits and ask whether an umbrella policy makes sense for your portfolio.
Check how each property is titled (personally or in an LLC) and make sure the named insured on each policy matches.
Ask about loss of rents (fair rental value) coverage in case a covered loss leaves a unit uninhabitable.
Look at flood coverage. Standard property policies typically exclude flood, and many Tampa Bay neighborhoods are flood-prone.
If you plan to buy, renovate or build in 2027, talk to us early about builder's risk or vacancy coverage.
Let's review your portfolio before renewal
Whether you own one rental condo or a dozen units, we will compare your current coverage with what is available in today's market. Schedule your free annual review in our office, at your home or a location of your choice, by video or phone, or by email. You can also request a quote at illuminationinsurance.com or call 813-445-5633.
Information is general and not legal or tax advice. Coverage and savings vary by company, property and underwriting; a quote is not a guarantee of coverage or price. Illumination Insurance Agency LLC is a Florida licensed insurance agency (#L094471). Source: Insurance Journal (Advocate Technologies data), November 2026; Florida Office of Insurance Regulation via ClickOrlando/WKMG, October 2026.
Have a Question? Message Our Team
Questions? Send us a note. For a quote, use the Request a Quote button.
By submitting, you agree to our Privacy Policy and to be contacted about your request. Please don't include Social Security, driver's license or bank numbers.